When a step is not a step! Specificity analysis of five physical activity monitors
O’Connell, Sandra Ó Laighin, Gearóid Quinlan, Leo R.
O’Connell, Sandra
Ó Laighin, Gearóid
Quinlan, Leo R.
Loading...
Publication Date
2017-01-13
Keywords
Type
Article
Downloads
Citation
O’Connell, Sandra, ÓLaighin, Gearóid, & Quinlan, Leo R. (2017). When a Step Is Not a Step! Specificity Analysis of Five Physical Activity Monitors. PLOS ONE, 12(1), e0169616. doi: 10.1371/journal.pone.0169616
Abstract
IntroductionPhysical activity is an essential aspect of a healthy lifestyle for both physical and mental health states. As step count is one of the most utilized measures for quantifying physical activity it is important that activity-monitoring devices be both sensitive and specific in recording actual steps taken and disregard non-stepping body movements. The objective of this study was to assess the specificity of five activity monitors during a variety of prescribed non-stepping activities.MethodsParticipants wore five activity monitors simultaneously for a variety of prescribed activities including deskwork, taking an elevator, taking a bus journey, automobile driving, washing and drying dishes; functional reaching task; indoor cycling; outdoor cycling; and indoor rowing. Each task was carried out for either a specific duration of time or over a specific distance. Activity monitors tested were the ActivPAL micro (TM), NL-2000 (TM) pedometer, Withings Smart Activity Monitor Tracker (Pulse O-2)(TM), Fitbit One (TM) and Jawbone UP (TM). Participants were video-recorded while carrying out the prescribed activities and the false positive step count registered on each activity monitor was obtained and compared to the video.ResultsAll activity monitors registered a significant number of false positive steps per minute during one or more of the prescribed activities. The Withings (TM) activity performed best, registering a significant number of false positive steps per minute during the outdoor cycling activity only (P = 0.025). The Jawbone (TM) registered a significant number of false positive steps during the functional reaching task and while washing and drying dishes, which involved arm and hand movement (P
Funder
Publisher
Public Library of Science
Publisher DOI
Rights
Attribution-NonCommercial-NoDerivs 3.0 Ireland